Home › Blog › Buying a French house together: indivision, SCI or tontine
Buying

Buying a French house together: indivision, SCI or tontine

A new build house in the Manche, southern Normandy

Two or more people buying a house in France together face a decision that is taken at the notaire's desk, usually in about two minutes, and governs everything that happens afterwards for as long as anyone owns the property.

Most people do not realise they are making it. The notaire asks how you wish to hold the property, somebody says "jointly, I suppose", and the default applies.

Sometimes the default is right. Often it is not. Here are the three options, what each actually does, and how to tell them apart.

This is general information and not legal advice. Which structure suits you depends on who you are, who else is involved and what you want to happen in thirty years, and that is a conversation for a notaire — ideally before you sign the compromis rather than at completion.

Indivision: the default

If you say nothing, you buy en indivision. Each person owns a stated proportion — a quote-part — of the whole property rather than a specific part of it.

The shares can and should be unequal. This is the single most common mistake. If one of you puts in sixty per cent of the money and the deed says fifty-fifty, you have made a gift of ten per cent, with the tax consequences that follow, and you will not be able to unpick it later. Tell the notaire what each person is actually contributing and have the deed say so.

Decisions. Day-to-day management — ordinary repairs, granting a long lease — needs a two-thirds majority of the shares. Anything amounting to disposal of the property, which means selling it or mortgaging it, needs unanimity. One person in ten can stop a sale.

The rule that catches everyone. Article 815 of the Code civil says nobody can be compelled to remain in indivision. Any co-owner, at any time, can demand that the property be sold so they can take their share out. If the others will not agree, they can go to court and force a judicial sale — licitation — which is slow, expensive, and rarely achieves a good price.

Read that twice if you are buying with a sibling, a friend or a grown-up child. Your ownership lasts exactly as long as the least committed person wants it to.

On death. The deceased's share passes to their heirs under the ordinary rules. Your co-owner's children, who you may barely know and who may want their money, become your co-owners.

Taming it. A convention d'indivision is a written agreement between the co-owners that can fix how decisions are taken, who may use the house and when, who pays what, and what happens if someone wants out, including a right for the others to buy them first. Signed for a fixed term of up to five years, renewable, it suspends the right to demand a sale for that period. It costs very little next to the arguments it prevents, and almost nobody does it.

Tontine: the survivor takes everything

A clause de tontine, also called a clause d'accroissement, is a short paragraph put into the purchase deed. Its effect is that when the first of you dies, the survivor is treated as having been the sole owner from the day of purchase — the deceased is deemed never to have owned any of it.

The property therefore does not enter the deceased's estate at all. It passes to nobody but the survivor, and the children's reserved share does not touch it.

For a couple who want to be certain the other can stay in the house, this is the most watertight arrangement French law offers.

The price of that certainty is rigidity. Neither of you can sell your share, mortgage it separately or give it away while you are both alive. The clause cannot be removed without the agreement of both. If the relationship ends badly, you are tied to each other through the house until you can agree — and if you cannot agree, you are genuinely stuck. Some banks are also reluctant to lend against a tontine for exactly that reason.

It can only be done at purchase. It goes into the deed on the day. It cannot be added afterwards.

The tax is where it turns. For a married couple or PACS partners it is efficient, because transfers between spouses and civil partners are free of inheritance tax whatever the amount. For an unmarried couple it can be punishing: the survivor is in principle taxed on the deceased's share at the rate applying between unrelated people, which is sixty per cent. There is a narrow exception for a modest main residence, with a value limit, and whether you fall inside it is precisely the sort of question to put to the notaire rather than to the internet.

So: tontine is usually a good idea for a married or PACS couple who want simplicity, and a potentially expensive one for an unmarried couple buying something substantial.

SCI: owning shares instead of bricks

A société civile immobilière is a company whose purpose is to hold property. You and your co-buyers become associés holding shares, and the company owns the house. You need at least two people.

What it solves. The statutes — the company's own rulebook, written when you set it up — decide how decisions are taken and what majority each kind of decision needs. You are no longer at the mercy of article 815. Nobody can force a sale of the house; the most anyone can do is try to sell their shares, and the statutes can give the others first refusal.

What it is really good at is passing property down gradually. Because shares are moveable property rather than land, a parent can give a block of shares to each child every fifteen years within the tax-free allowance, keeping control through the statutes and the usufruct while the value moves across. Over twenty or thirty years a substantial house can pass to the next generation having paid very little.

What it costs. Setting one up runs to roughly one to two thousand euros. After that it is a company: annual accounts, an annual general meeting with minutes, and a registered office. If that sounds like a chore, it is, and it goes on for as long as the SCI exists.

Three traps worth naming.

Furnished short-term letting through an SCI is treated as a commercial activity and can push the company into corporation tax, which changes the treatment of your eventual capital gain considerably and is close to irreversible. If you intend to let the house out furnished, say so before anyone drafts anything.

An SCI loses the architect exemption. An individual building a house of up to 150 square metres does not need an architect. A property held through a company has no such exemption at any size, so an SCI building a modest house must still engage one.

And for anyone with United States tax obligations, an SCI can be treated unhelpfully by the American system. That is a question for a cross-border specialist before you form anything, not afterwards.

If you are married, your regime is already deciding things

Couples often skip this and should not. The matrimonial regime under which you married — and which law applies to it, if you married outside France — governs whether the house is jointly owned, separately owned, or something in between, and it interacts with everything above.

A couple married under a separation of property regime who buy en indivision in unequal shares have a quite different arrangement from the same couple under a community regime. Both are fine. What is not fine is not knowing which you are.

Tell the notaire where and when you married and under what regime, and let them tell you what applies. It takes five minutes.

Choosing, in plain terms

A married or PACS couple buying a home for the two of you. Indivision is usually fine, and a tontine clause adds certainty for the survivor at modest cost. Consider the tontine particularly where there are children from earlier relationships.

An unmarried couple. Indivision with carefully recorded unequal shares and a convention d'indivision, plus wills. Think hard before a tontine because of the sixty per cent.

Friends or siblings buying together. A convention d'indivision at the very least. If the plan is long-term, an SCI, because article 815 will otherwise hang over the arrangement permanently.

Parents buying with an eye on the children. An SCI, almost always, for the gradual gifting.

One person buying alone. None of this applies — but the succession rules still do, and we have a separate article on who inherits your French house.

Why it is easier on a new build

All of this is settled in the deed, and a new build gives you a clean one. There is no inherited title with a great-aunt's right of way on it, no boundary that has not been surveyed since 1958, and no previous owner's arrangement to unpick.

You are also buying land first and building afterwards, which means you are sitting with a notaire at the start of the process with plenty of time to think, rather than signing something complicated at the end of a chain. The tontine clause in particular can only go into the deed at that moment, so it is worth raising at the first meeting.

We build across Brittany, Normandy and the Vendée, every house on a fixed inclusive price with the notaire's fees inside the figure we quote. We are not lawyers and we do not give legal advice, but we make sure the question is asked at the point where you still have every option open. Book a free half-hour, or reach us on WhatsApp or by email for a same-day reply. You can also see what each of our plots comes to, all in, with the build cost calculator.

Not ready to talk yet?

Take the guide instead

Thirty-two pages on the CCMI contract, what the notaire really charges on building land, RE2020, the ten-year guarantees and the real budget. Free, and nobody rings you.

Get the free guide Or ask us one question

Thinking about a move to France?

Book a free 30-minute call with a bilingual adviser who lives and works here.

Book a Free Call